Quick Verdict
ClickMagick is the better fit for affiliates, funnel owners, ecommerce stores and agencies that want to start immediately, pay a flat published price, and get bot filtering and tracked links alongside attribution.
Cometly suits teams that want CRM-connected, cross-channel revenue attribution and prefer a demo-led onboarding, including B2B companies tracking leads through a sales pipeline.
Try ClickMagick FreeClickMagick vs Cometly at a Glance
| ClickMagick | Cometly | |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2014 | 2021 |
| How you start | Self-serve 14-day free trial | Demo call |
| Pricing basis | Tracked visitors; flat plans | Monthly pageviews; quoted plans |
| Starting price | $79/mo ($66 annually) | Metadata mentions $150/seat/mo |
| Annual saving | About 17% (two months) | 20% |
| Conversion syncing | Meta, Google, TikTok, Microsoft and more | Conversion API with 14+ parameters per event |
| Bot filtering + Click Shield | Yes | Not a focus |
| Affiliate link tools | Yes, unlimited affiliate projects | Not a focus |
Who Each Tool Is Built For
Cometly is a newer attribution platform, founded in 2021, that connects ad clicks, website visits and CRM data to revenue. Its marketing emphasizes cross-channel attribution and sending rich conversion data back to ad platforms, and it positions itself for teams including B2B SaaS companies.
ClickMagick has been around since 2014 and grew from a link tracker into an attribution platform. It's built for marketers who buy traffic directly and want hands-off accuracy: first-party tracking, bot filtering, tracked links and real-time conversion syncing.
Pricing and Getting Started
Cometly's pricing page lists Core and Enterprise plans, priced by monthly pageviews, with a 20% saving for annual billing. There's no free trial listed; you book a 30-minute demo. Its page metadata mentions pricing starting at $150 per seat per month.
ClickMagick publishes its prices: Starter at $79 a month for 10,000 visitors, Standard at $199 for 100,000 and Pro at $349 for 1,000,000, with annual billing saving about two months. You can start a 14-day trial today and new customers get a 30-day money-back guarantee. For small teams, ClickMagick is usually the cheaper and faster way to get going. See ClickMagick pricing.
Sending Data Back to Ad Platforms
Both tools treat conversion syncing as core. Cometly highlights that its Conversion API sends 14 or more parameters per event to help platforms match conversions to people. ClickMagick's Audience Optimization sends real conversions in real time with first-party visitor details to raise match quality, and lets you choose which conversion types to send.
In practice, both approaches aim at the same goal: giving Meta and Google better signals. The deciding factors are usually price, onboarding style and the extras each tool includes.
Where ClickMagick Adds More
- Bot filtering and Click Shield: cleaner reports and fewer wasted paid clicks.
- Tracked links and Smart Links: for email, solo ads, social bios and print.
- Affiliate tools: Affiliate Link Builder, postback support and unlimited affiliate projects.
- Agency features: a free Business Manager and a 35% discount for approved agencies.
When Cometly Is the Better Choice
- You want attribution tied closely to a CRM and sales pipeline.
- You'd rather have a guided, demo-led setup.
- Seat-based, pageview-based pricing fits your team.
When ClickMagick Is the Better Choice
Start Today
Free trial, no call required, published prices.
Promoting Offers
Tracked links, postbacks and bot filtering built in.
Cutting Junk Clicks
Click Shield excludes repeat and suspicious clickers.
Small Teams
From $66 a month on annual billing.
Our Recommendation
If you want to start tracking today without a sales process, and you value bot filtering and tracked links, start with ClickMagick. If your attribution question lives inside a CRM pipeline and you want a guided setup, book a Cometly demo and compare its quote with ClickMagick's published plans.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cometly better than ClickMagick?
Cometly suits teams that want CRM-connected, cross-channel attribution with a demo-led onboarding, including B2B companies. ClickMagick suits affiliates, funnel owners, stores and agencies that want self-serve setup, bot filtering, tracked links and flat published pricing.
How much does Cometly cost?
Cometly's pricing page offers Core and Enterprise plans, with pricing based on monthly pageviews and annual billing saving 20%. Its page metadata mentions a starting price of $150 per seat per month, but exact pricing is quoted. ClickMagick starts at $79 a month, or $66 billed annually.
Does Cometly have a free trial?
Cometly's pricing page doesn't list a free trial; it offers a demo call instead. ClickMagick has a 14-day free trial on every plan.
Do both send conversions back to Meta and Google?
Yes. Cometly says its Conversion API sends 14 or more parameters per event. ClickMagick's Audience Optimization sends real conversions, with first-party visitor details, to Meta, Google, TikTok and Microsoft.
Which is better for affiliate marketers?
ClickMagick. It includes tracked links, an Affiliate Link Builder, postback support, bot filtering and unlimited affiliate projects on every plan, which Cometly isn't built around.
Start With ClickMagick's Free Trial
No demo call needed. Install the tracking code, connect your ad accounts and see real attribution data on your own traffic.
Try ClickMagick Free